App developers Musi and Sarafan Mobile have sued Apple and Google in California federal court over app removals they claim were unjustified, highlighting tensions over the tech giants’ intellectual property enforcement policies. Musi’s music-streaming app was removed after YouTube complained about interface infringement, while Sarafan’s “Reely” app was taken down following Instagram’s claims about logo similarity.
Both developers say the platforms breached their agreements by removing apps without sufficient evidence. The lawsuits underscore broader concerns about Apple and Google’s dominance in app distribution. Their private IP dispute systems operate outside traditional legal frameworks, with platforms making unilateral decisions that can effectively shut down businesses, according to University of New Hampshire law professor Peter Karol. […]
“In a court proceeding, you can see here’s a complaint with the allegations, and then we have the defendant respond, and then we have a judge come out with an opinion saying, ‘Is the mark valid? Is the mark infringed?'” said Lisa Ramsey, law professor at University of San Diego. Google and Apple’s systems, meanwhile, are “a black box.”
